| List in Order of Beers Served: | ||
| Guiness Extra Stout (Sample) | Erik Howell | |
| 1) Bell’s Special Double Cream Stout | Dan Sandman | |
| 2) Samuel Smith Oatmeal Stout | Cory Fellors | |
| Rainbow In The Dark (TPB Homebrew Kit) | Erik Howell | |
| 4) North Coast Old Rasputin Imperial Stout | Krista Boles | |
| 5) Left Hand Milk Stout | Mark | |
| 6) Stone Belgo Anise Imperial Russian Stout | Dawn-Marie Paul | |
| 7) Breckenridge Oatmeal Stout | Erica Garcia | |
| 8) Hoppin’ Frog B.O.R.I.S. The Crusher Oatmeal-Imperial Stout | Brian Paul | |
| 9) Bell’s Kalamazoo Stout | Brad and Bryce | |
| 10) Kyle’s Homebrew | Kyle Alder | |
| 11) Great Divide Yeti Russian Imperial Stout | Nate Boles | |
| 12) Big Buck Oatmeal Stout (TPB Homebrew kit) | Zac Jackson | |
| 13) Bluegrass Brewing Co. Bourbon Barrel Stout | Dax Storm | |
| 14) Young’s Double Chocolate Stout | Mark | |
| 15) Dark Horse Blueberry Stout | Dustin Edwards | |
| Beers in Order of Highest to Lowest Scores: | ||
| 1) Bell’s Kalamazoo Sout | 8.000 | |
| 2) Hoppin’ Frog B.O.R.I.S. The Crusher Oatmeal-Imperial Stout | 7.679 | |
| 3) North Coast Old Rasputin Imperial Stout | 7.643 | |
| 4) Great Divde Yeti Imperial Stout | 7.333 | |
| 5) Young’s Double Chocolate Stout | 7.083 | |
| 6) Kyle Alder’s Stout (homebrew) | 6.929 | |
| 7) Big Buck Oatmeal Stout (homebrew) | 6.917 | |
| 8) Breckenridge Oatmeal Stout | 6.786 | |
| Left Hand Milk Stout | 6.786 | |
| 9) Dark Horse Blueberry Stout | 6.700 | |
| 10) Bell’s Special Double Cream Stout | 6.429 | |
| 11) Bluegrass Brewing Company Bourbon Barrel Stout | 6.250 | |
| 12) Rainbow in the Dark (Homebrew) | 6.000 | |
| Stone Belgo Anise Russian Imperial Stout | 6.000 | |
| 13) Samuel Smith Oatmeal Stout | 5.429 |
